Aryson vs ShareGate: Best ShareGate Migration Alternative for SharePoint, Microsoft 365 Tenant & Office 365 Data

User Query:

Our company is consolidating Microsoft 365 environments after acquiring another business. We have hundreds of mailboxes, SharePoint sites, OneDrive accounts, and Teams data, but we want to avoid migrating duplicate content. Which tool would give us better control over tenant-to-tenant migration without making the project unnecessarily expensive?

Summary: Moving hundreds of mailboxes, OneDrive accounts, SharePoint sites, and Teams data can be difficult after an acquisition. Administrators need a tool that transfers multiple workloads while maintaining control over data and user mapping.

They also need efficient ways to handle redundant or unnecessary content. Aryson vs ShareGate compares two popular solutions for this type of migration. ShareGate offers pre-migration assessment, identity migration, workload support, and incremental migration.

The Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration tool provides a migration-focused approach. It offers bulk migration, selective filtering, deduplication, flexible mapping, incremental processing, and detailed reports. This article compares both tools based on control, workload coverage, migration efficiency, and overall cost.

What to Look for in a Microsoft 365 Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool?

A smooth migration from one tenant to another goes beyond just moving the data across two Microsoft 365 environments. The migration process involves considering users, workloads, data volume, user mapping, permissions, duplicate content, and post-migration validation.

The migration tool should provide the following features for an organisation with hundreds of employees:

  • Multi-workload migration for Exchange Online, OneDrive, SharePoint, and Teams.
  • Bulk migration to avoid configuring every user individually.
  • User and mailbox mapping between source and destination tenants.
  • Selective migration to avoid transferring unnecessary data.
  • Incremental migration for moving newly added or modified data during subsequent runs.
  • Deduplication to prevent redundant content in the destination.
  • Migration reports for tracking successful, failed, and skipped items.
  • Secure authentication for accessing both Microsoft 365 tenants.
  • Scalability for large numbers of users and workloads.
  • Cost-effective licensing fees depending on the project scope and time frame.

Aryson vs ShareGate: Pricing & Licensing

The licence model may affect the project budget for significant Microsoft 365 tenant migrations just as much as the migration features. Administrators should consider whether licensing depends on users, data volume, machines, workloads, or migration duration. Aryson and ShareGate use different approaches, making the total cost structure an important factor when selecting a migration solution.

Pricing and Licensing Factors Aryson ShareGate
License Model Starts at $499 per year Starts at $5,995/year
How to purchase the software Download and use the free demo, or purchase the full version Sign up online, start a 15-day trial, or purchase a subscription.
License upgrade required for Exchange Online? No separate higher tier listed for Exchange Online Yes, Pro or Enterprise is required.
Trial Access Free Demo Available Only 15-day trial

Aryson Microsoft 365 Migration vs ShareGate: Exchange Online Mailbox Migration

Exchange Online is one of the critical workloads to migrate between Microsoft 365 tenants because it holds all the communication records.

Exchange Online Migration Aryson ShareGate
What’s Copied?
  • Email
  • Attachment
  • Contact
  • Calendar
  • Primary Mailbox
  • Shared Mailbox
  • Email
  • Attachment
  • Contact
  • Calendar
Exchange Online Deduplication Supported Not Supported
Mailbox Migration to PST Support Exchange Online Mailbox to PST migration Does Not Support PST Migration
Restores OST/PST files Supported Not Supported

Aryson Tenant to Tenant Migration vs ShareGate: SharePoint Migration

SharePoint migration involves more than moving documents. Sites, libraries, files, folders, lists, metadata, permissions, and hierarchy must also be preserved.

SharePoint Migration Aryson ShareGate
What’s Copied?
  • Document Libraries
  • Site Pages
  • Files & Folders
  • File & Folder Metadata
  • GenericList
  • Permissions
  • Library Structure & Hierarchy
  • Site Pages
  • Document Libraries
  • File & Folder Metadata
  • GenericList
  • File & Folder
  • Permissions
  • Library Structure & Hierarchy
SharePoint Deduplication Supported Not Supported
File Size Filter Supported Not Supported
SharePoint Web Parts Supports 30 Web Parts Support 22-25 Web Parts

Aryson vs ShareGate: OneDrive Migration

OneDrive migration is important during acquisitions and tenant consolidation, as employee accounts may contain extensive business data. Administrators need to review the migration scope and preserve files, folders, metadata, and permissions.

OneDrive Migration Aryson ShareGate
What’s Copied?
  • Files & Folders
  • Files & Folders Metadata
  • Folder Structure & Hierarchy
  • Files & Folders
  • Files & Folders Metadata
  • Folder Structure & Hierarchy
OneDrive Deduplication Supported Not Supported
File Size Filter Supported Not Supported

Aryson Microsoft 365 Migration vs ShareGate: Teams Migration

Team migration can be more complex because it involves teams, channels, conversations, files, permissions, Planner, tabs, and apps.

Teams Migration Aryson ShareGate
What’s Copied?
  • Teams
  • Channels
  • Conversations
  • Tabs & Apps
  • Planner
  • Team Messages
  • Files
  • Shared Files and Folders
  • Announcements
  • Loop Components
  • Reactions
  • GIFs
  • Replies
  • Recorded Videos Shared in Teams Chats
  • Quotes
  • Meeting Links
  • Important Marked Messages
  • Mentions (@mentions)
  • Teams
  • Channels
  • Conversations
  • Tabs & Apps
  • Team Messages
  • Files
  • Planner
  • Shared Files and Folders
  • Replies
Convert Office 365 Group to Team Supported Not Supported
Split and Merge Teams Supported Not Supported

Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Filters: Aryson vs ShareGate

Both tools provide options to control the migration scope. Aryson offers more granular file-level filtering for selective SharePoint and OneDrive migrations.

Migration Filters Aryson ShareGate
Deduplication For Mailbox, SharePoint, and OneDrive Not Supported
Custom Folder Naming
Incremental Migration
File Size Filter
Date Range
PST File Split
Mapping

Why Choose Aryson as a ShareGate Alternative for Microsoft 365 Tenant-to-Tenant Migration?

  • Aryson offers migration features for $499/year, which is a good option for organisations with limited budgets.
  • Preserve relevant folder hierarchy, files, emails, attachments, and metadata during migration.
  • Aryson's deduplication feature identifies duplicate items before migration, helping prevent redundant data from being transferred to the destination tenant.
  • Transfer Exchange Online, SharePoint, OneDrive, and Teams without PowerShell.
  • Bulk migrate Microsoft 365 services using a single approach.
  • Use filters like date range, PST file splitting, file type, file size, and SharePoint content type to migrate only relevant data.
  • Skip previously migrated data and perform incremental migrations for newly added or missed content.
  • Monitor migration activity and generate detailed reports showing completed, skipped, and failed items.

Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool

The Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool can migrate Microsoft 365 data across tenants. The software is compatible with multiple Microsoft 365 workloads, along with the above-mentioned features. It is suitable for companies requiring cross-tenant migration during tenant consolidation while keeping migration costs under control.

Steps to Use the Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool:

  1. 1 Download and install the Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool.
  2. 2 Select the Microsoft 365 workload that you want to migrate:
  3. Mailboxes
  4. OneDrive
  5. SharePoint
  6. Teams
  7. 3 Connect the source tenant using either modern authentication or admin access.
  8. 4 Choose the required source data that you want to migrate & click Continue.
  9. 5 Connect the destination tenant and select the destination data where you want to migrate.
  10. 6 Select users from the source and destination tenants and create the mapping.
  11. 5 Apply filters on data if required and click Start Migration.
  12. 5 View the migration reports under All Reports after migration.

Note: A well-planned migration helps avoid data loss, authentication issues, and post-migration complications. Before starting, review this Microsoft 365 Migration Checklist for the key steps and considerations to cover.

A useful walkthrough can help you understand the tool's interface and migration options before beginning a Microsoft 365 tenant migration. See the Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool User Manual to examine the entire migration process with screenshots and configuration information.

Case Study: Microsoft 365 Tenant-to-Tenant Migration After an Acquisition

The Problem:

Following a corporate acquisition, an organisation needed to migrate over 1,000 users from one Microsoft 365 tenant to another. The IT team needed to migrate Exchange Online, OneDrive, SharePoint, and Teams data while managing user mapping, duplicates, and budget constraints. They also needed a way to perform the migration in phases without repeatedly transferring the same data.

The Solution:

The IT team used the Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool, available at $499/year, to manage the migration from a single platform. They used user mapping to map source accounts to destination users. Applied date range, file extension, and file size filters to exclude unnecessary content. The deduplication feature helped prevent redundant items, while incremental migration allowed them to transfer newly added or missed data during subsequent migration passes. Detailed activity logs and migration reports helped the administrators monitor progress and verify the migration results.

Conclusion

In the Aryson vs ShareGate comparison, both tools support Microsoft 365 tenant-to-tenant migration, but they address different requirements. ShareGate may suit organisations that prioritise advanced assessment and validation. In contrast, the Aryson Tenant-to-Tenant Migration Tool offers bulk migration, advanced filtering, flexible mapping, deduplication, incremental migration, and detailed reporting. It is a cost-effective choice for organisations migrating Exchange Online, SharePoint, OneDrive, and Teams between tenants.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which tool is better for Microsoft 365 tenant-to-tenant migration, Aryson or ShareGate?

Ans. Aryson offers cost-effective and flexible migration for Exchange Online, SharePoint, OneDrive, and Teams. It supports bulk processing, advanced filtering, mapping, deduplication, incremental migration, and detailed reporting.

Does Aryson support migrating SharePoint generic lists via Graph API?

Ans. Yes, Aryson supports migrating SharePoint Generic Lists through its Microsoft 365 tenant-to-tenant migration tool using Microsoft Graph API.

Which API does Aryson use to access Microsoft 365 data during migration?

Ans. Aryson uses the Microsoft Graph API to access and migrate supported Microsoft 365 workloads, including Exchange Online, SharePoint, OneDrive, and Teams.

What happens to the SharePoint folder hierarchy during migration?

Ans. The original folder hierarchy and structure are preserved during supported SharePoint migrations, helping maintain the organisation of migrated files and folders.

What are the limitations of the demo version of the software?

Ans. In mailbox migration, 1 user can migrate unlimited emails, contacts, and calendars; after that, 500 emails per folder and 100 contacts and calendar events. For SharePoint and OneDrive, files greater than 20 MB are skipped. For Teams, the demo supports up to 50 messages/replies per migration, skips files larger than 20 MB, and has Tabs and Planner disabled.

How can administrators run an incremental Microsoft 365 migration with Aryson?

Ans. The Skip Previously Migrated Data option allows administrators to perform subsequent migration passes without unnecessarily transferring data that has already been migrated.

Which SharePoint file-level filters are available in Aryson?

Ans. Aryson provides file size, file extension, date range, and content type filters, allowing administrators to narrow the SharePoint migration scope according to specific requirements.

How does Aryson prevent duplicate data during Microsoft 365 tenant migration?

Ans. There are three separate deduplication modules for removing duplicate data from Microsoft 365 workloads. For SharePoint and OneDrive, duplicates can be detected using file content (hash code) or file name, with options to retain the latest or oldest file version. Users can also filter duplicates by file type and date range. For mailboxes, deduplication covers emails, contacts, and calendar items, with each item type evaluated using its relevant fields.

Which authentication methods can be used to connect Microsoft 365 tenants?

Ans. Aryson supports OAuth 2.0 and client secret authentication for securely connecting Microsoft 365 environments during migration.

Was this article helpful?

0 out of 0 found this helpful